February 9, 2012

Legislator cites recent child murder case in speaking out against abortion

Betty De Boef

A state representative who opposes abortion suggests two Iowa women who’ve been suspected of killing their babies were “confused” because of the U.S. Supreme Court’s 1972 Roe v Wade decision.

Representative Betty De Boef, a Republican from What Cheer, cites the case of a Huxley woman who has been charged with first-degree murder for killing her twin newborn girls earlier this month.

“The young woman…listened too well to the message that she has heard all of her 22 years…This ruling tells young girls that the product of their womb is only valuable if they want it. It tells them that if they do not, it is expendable,” De Boef says.

 ”I submit to you that this tragic occurrence is a direct result of the message that we have sent her.” De Boef also points to the case of a 19-year-old Charles City woman whose premature baby allegedly disappeared after being delivered in a Mason City restroom.

“The irony of this is all they had to do was seek the serves of a LeRoy Carhart, possibly only a few weeks prior, and they would be home free,” De Boef says. “No wonder they are confused.” Le Roy Carhart is a Nebraska doctor who performs late-term abortions.

A bill designed to ensure Carhart can’t establish a practice in Iowa failed to pass during the 2011 Iowa legislative session. The Charles City woman has not been charged; authorities say she is not cooperating with the investigation. De Boef’s comments came during a speech early this afternoon in the Iowa House, during “points of personal privilege.”

De Boef, who decried the state of the nation’s court system, blasted an Iowa judge’s ruling that two other Iowa women have both their names listed as the “natural parents” on a birth certificate.

“If this were not so egregious, it would be laughable, just ask any third grader,” De Boef says. “…These sad cases are a direct result of…numerous court rulings based on the foolishness of humanity, not nature, not nature’s laws.” De Boef, a farm wife and mother to four biological children and six foster kids, is currently serving in her 12th year in the Iowa House.

She does not plan to seek reelection.

Perry: “God was working on my heart” (audio)

Four Republican presidential hopefuls participated tonight in a radio forum organized by PersonhoodUSA, a group pushing congress to pass a bill declaring that life begins at conception and one candidate revealed his views on the issue have changed.

Rick Perry, who has opposed nearly all abortions, said he no longer favors exceptions in cases of rape or incest. Perry recently met with a woman who was conceived in a rape.

“Looking in her eyes, I couldn’t come up with an answer to defend the exceptions for rape and incest,” Perry said.

Perry met the woman earlier this month when he attended the premiere of a documentary called “The Gift of Life”.

“She made a statement to me that was really profound and pierced my heart,” Perry said.

Perry has touted what he calls his “pro-life credentials” on the campaign trail, acting to “defund” Planned Parenthood in Texas, where he is governor, and requiring parental consent there before a minor can obtain an abortion. But Perry has supported abortion exceptions in cases of rape and incest, or when the mother’s life is endangered by the pregnancy. But he unveiled during tonight’s telephone town hall meeting with abortion foes that he had undergone a transformation this Christmas season.

“All I can tell you is God was working on my heart,” Perry said.  (Audio of Perry’s remarks posted here.)

Organizers said nearly 26,000 people listened to the event by telephone. It was broadcast nationally on The Steve Deace Show and another radio network.

“Fracture” among Iowa’s social conservatives

Two men who announced at a morning news conference they’re backing Rick Santorum’s bid for the White House have ignited a firestorm within the state’s social conservative community that is likely to linger long after the Caucuses are over. 

Bob Vander Plaats, a three-time candidate for governor, is president of The Family Leader, a group that has led the charge against gay marriage in Iowa. Chuck Hurley, a former state legislator, is the long-time president of The Iowa Family Policy Center, which is part of The Family Leader organization. Both are now backing Santorum. In speaking with reporters this morning, Hurley acknowledged the rift among religious conservatives in Iowa — and even publicly cited the vow from a fellow “cultural warrior” to burn Bob Vander Plaats in effigy for the way this decision came down.

“Today, I want to extend an olive branch to any and every overheated former friend in this movement,” Hurley said.

Vander Plaats said he “didn’t want to get into” the conflict. 

“January 4 is also coming,” Vander Plaats said, a reference to the day after the Iowa Caucuses. “And on January 4, we need to get along again. We all need to come together.” 

Hurley, though, wasn’t willing to let it go.

“Those sort of threats being breathed out need to be confronted and not just swept under the rug,” Hurley said. “Until that individual deals with his own anger problem, those sort of things will divide and they’ll hurt our opportunity to coalesce around a pro-family candidate and they’ll hurt our opportunity to win the Iowa Senate back.”

It seems a bit like airing “dirty laundry” in public to Craig Robinson who the Iowa GOP’s political director for the 2008 campaign.

“This is definitely something that should probably be settled privately instead of aired at the endorsement,” Robinson said during an interview with Radio Iowa this afternoon. “I just think it kind of distracts from the purpose of today’s press conference.” 

Robinson runs www.TheIowaRepublican.com, a for-profit website. Back in the 2000 Iowa Caucus cycle, Robinson was working on the Steve Forbes campaign.

“I’m not surprised that there’s hard feelings,” Robinson said. “There’s always hard feelings in campaigns, but this one seems to be a little more out in the open.” 

Steve Scheffler is the leader of the Iowa Faith and Freedom Coalition, another conservative group which hosted events with all the candidates — but decided not to endorse a single candidate.

“Through experience in working on three caucus campaigns as a staffer and thinking that I’m a pretty good salesman, at the end of the day an endorsement doesn’t really mean much, especially when candidates are quite similar on the issues,” Scheffler said this afternoon during a telephone interview with Radio Iowa. “And sometimes I think it causes some divisions and some hard feelings among people who say, ‘Why didn’t you endorse my candidate…who was just as good as the candidate that you endorsed?’”

Danny Carroll, the former president of The Family Leader’s board, has endorsed Michele Bachmann. During an interview earlier this afternoon, Carroll stressed the decision from The Family Leader’s board to remain neutral in the race.

“It’s not too surprising and really, probably even an indication of a broader fragmentation across the whole slate of candidates,” Carroll said.

Doug Gross, a Republican who has warned of the danger in a “camp Christian” dynamic in Iowa’s Republican Party, said this endorsement episode illustrates the “fracture” among Iowa’s religious conservatives.

“It helps Romney because generally the evangelical community appears to be united around only one thing and that’s to be certain that he doesn’t win,” Gross told Radio Iowa. “I thought there might be some desire might help them unite around one of their candidates, so as a result of them splitting up their negative feelings toward him, it enhances (Romney’s) chances.”

Santorum has “problems” with recent Gingrich statement on abortion

Four Republican presidential candidates spoke tonight to a crowd of 1400 gathered in Des Moines for the premiere of a documentary called “The Gift of Life.”  

Rick Santorum used part of his speech to question rival Newt Gingrich’s committment on the abortion issue.

“I have some problems with some of the folks, you know, running for office these days when they say, “I believe life begins at conception,” Santorum said.

Gingrich issued a statement earlier this week to The Family Leader, a conservative Christian group, that is considering giving its endorsement to Gingrich. Gingrich wrote he believes “that life begins at conception.” Santorum ridiculed it.

“It’s like (saying), ‘I believe the sun rises,’” Santorum said, and the crowd began laughing and erupted in applause, cheers and whistles as Santorum added: “Why would you say you believe something that’s a fact.”

Gingrich — during his remarks to the crowd earlier in the evening — said the “central, moral question of our lifetime” is abortion.

“The whole reason behind Roe v Wade is a utilitarian, phony science reasoning that has collapsed under the weight of modern technology,” Gingrich said. “The fact is that as the country became more aware of Roe v Wade, it has turned more and more against abortion.”

The crowd applauded Gingrich when he declared that as president, he would ensure federal money is not spent on any abortion anywhere in the world. The crowd sat, hushed, as Michele Bachmann spoke of her own miscarriage.

“That little baby was 12 weeks old…That baby was perfect. I know without a shadow of a doubt every baby that God creates is perfect,” Bachmann said, “because we are created in the image and likeness of a holy God.”

Bachmann promised to “protect life” as president. Rick Perry criticized judges who “impose their beliefs” through their opinions and vowed to help pass a “human life amendment” to the U.S. constitution.

“The greatest victories in the battle for life is not going to be won in the halls of government. It’s going to be won in the hearts of men,” Perry said. “Yes, we must change the laws, but we must also change hearts and minds.”

Former Arkansas Governor Mike Huckabee, the victor in the 2008 Iowa Caucuses, was the host of tonight’s documentary premiere in Des Moines.  

“You know this event is not here to endorse a candidate, but I think it is significant that all four of the candidates present tonight have endorsed life and that ought to be very important for you to consider someone to vote for in the caucuses here in Iowa,” Huckabee said.

In other news from the campaign trail, Perry kicked off his 44-city bus tour with stops in western Iowa. Michele Bachmann described the grinding process of running for president as akin to having “the snot beat out of you” and Newt Gingrich was heckled by a pack of protestors as he started to give a lecture in Iowa City.

Could a written statement from Gingrich secure Family Leader’s backing?

Republican candidate Newt Gingrich has “solemnly” vowed to defend traditional marriage if he’s elected president.

Gingrich sent a written statement to The Family Leader, a conservative group based in Iowa which produced a wide-ranging “Marriage Vow” pledge for the candidates this summer. Gingrich, who has been divorced twice, wrote that he would “uphold the institution of marriage” by being faithful to his third wife, Calista, and by respecting “the marital bonds of others.”

Gingrich also expressed support for an amendment to the U.S. constitution which would ban same-sex marriage.

Gingrich wrote that he believes “life begins at conception” and, as president, he would sign legislation to provide “greater protections for the unborn.”

By far the longest paragraph in the Gingrich statement, however, was a wide-ranging set of declarations about the federal court system. Gingrich said unelected federal judges had caused a “constitutional crisis” because, according to Gingrich, the public has lost confidence in the courts. 

“Obviously, I think all of us wish he just would have signed our pledge,” Bob Vander Plaats, CEO of The Family Leader, told Radio Iowa this evening. “But when you read his pledge, it almost begs the question of, you know, ‘Why didn’t you sign our pledge?’ because (the Gingrich statement) is a very strong pledge as it relates to the sanctity of human life, God’s design for the family with one-man/one-woman marriage.”

The Family Leader’s board of directors will meet again this weekend to ponder endorsing a candidate. 

“I think the board and myself are like many caucus-goers. We’re just like of up in the air yet,” Vander Plaats said. “…I think after Thursday night’s debate, we along with caucus-goers are going to have to make up our mind on which candidate we’re going to support.”

It is possible Vander Plaats will personally endorse a candidate if The Family Leader’s board of directors decides against endorsing. There has been speculation Vander Plaats was leaning toward supporting Gingrich, but Vander Plaats told Radio Iowa he is among the ranks of the undecided.

“If Darla and I were to caucus tonight, we’d first have to have a caucus in our living room to determine who we’re going to caucus for,” Vander Plaats said. Darla is Vander Plaats’s wife.

Gingrich helped Vander Plaats and his allies financially in 2010 in their successful effort to oust three Iowa Supreme Court justices who had ruled in favor of same-sex marriage.

Santorum reaches #99 tonight in Maquoketa

Republican presidential hopeful Rick Santorum’s visit to Maquoketa this evening will mark a milestone that no other presidential candidate is likely to cross this year. Santorum will have made a campaign stop in each of Iowa’s 99 counties.

“It’s more important for me because…it’s the first caucus,” Santorum said Monday during a stop in Decorah. “Number two, the values of the people here, I think, are very much in conformity with the Republican Party nationwide.” 

Surveys of 2008 Iowa Caucus-goers indicated about 60 percent identified themselves as evangelical or born-again Christians and Caucus critics charge Iowa’s Republican Party is too conservative — too focused on social issues like abortion and same-sex marriage. Santorum’s opposition to abortion and same-sex marriage aligns him with the party’s conservatives, but he argues Iowa Republicans aren’t focused exclusively on social issues.
:21  :across the country.”

“This is a state that is concerned about all the issues: the moral/cultural issues, the economic issues, the national security issues,” Santorum said.  “It’s not a singular-focused state and I think that’s where most Republicans are around the country and so if you can do well here, that really reflects well on your ability to do well in Republican primaries across the country.”

Santorum began his day in Sigourney. He’s made a mid-morning stop at the Java Lounge in Williamsburg.  He’s scheduled to be in Fairfield, Keosauqua and Wapello this afternoon before his visit to Maquoketa at 7 p.m.

(Darin Swenson from KDEC Radio contributed to this report.)

Cain’s “inconsistent” or “confused” answer on abortion a target (audio)

Republican presidential candidate Herman Cain says he believes statements he made in Iowa this weekend have reestablished his credibility among conservatives on the abortion issue, but the more than 1000 Iowa Republicans who witnessed Cain’s remarks were given a leaflet afterwards with this accusation: “Herman Cain threw the babies under the bus.”

Cain was among six Republican candidates who spoke Saturday at the Iowa Faith and Freedom Coalition’s fall fundraiser on the state fairgrounds and he made this simple declaration during his 10-minute speech: “From conception, no abortions, no exceptions.”

A host of the event also asked each candidate what they would do, as president, to end “abortion on demand.” Cain gave a 40-second answer on the topic.  

“I would not sign any legislation where government funded abortion. I would not sign any legislation that in any way allowed the government to be involved in it,” Cain said. “I would strengthen all of our current laws that prevent abortion. I believe that abortion should be clearly stated and illegal across this country.” 

Cain’s answer first drew applause from the crowd when he vowed to forbid any federal tax dollars from going to Planned Parenthood.

“And I will make sure that I appoint judges that will enforce the constitution — no activist judges — and I would also make sure that we didn’t allow any bureaucrats to get in the way in order to protect the life of the unborn,” Cain said, to more applause.

During an appearance on CNN last week, Cain said families should make the ultimate “choice” about some abortions, a remark reprinted on the leaflet placed on every vehicle parked around the hall where Cain spoke. It came from a group called “Iowans for Some Semblance of Christian Decency.” Rival Rick Perry was the only one of the other five candidates to directly challenge Cain on the issue.

“It is a liberal canard to say, ‘I am personally pro-life but government should stay out of that decision.’ If that is your view, you are not pro-life,” Perry said, as the crowd started applauding.  “You are pro-having-your-cake-and-eating-it-too. We respect life.”

The Texas governor used more than three minutes in his 10-minute speech to the crowd to talk about what Perry described as his “unwavering stand” on the abortion issue, including his approval of Texas laws which require minors to get parental consent before obtaining an abortion and a law which requires women seeking an abortion to see a sonogram first.   

“On this issue you don’t just need to listen to my words,” Perry said. “But you can look at my record.” 

Rick Santorum, the final candidate to speak Saturday, indirectly questioned Cain’s sincerity. 

“You’ve heard a lot of policy…The choice for you is to whether the folks that are delivering this are authentic,” Santorum said. “Can they be trusted?”

During an interview with Radio Iowa, Ron Paul expressed some compassion for Cain’s predicament, but Paul also summed up the problem Cain now faces.

“Obviously he’s come across as either being inconsistent or very confused on that,” Paul said.  “And this is one issue that supporters of the issue — they don’t want confusion.” 

In addition to the leaflet distributed Saturday night which attacked Cain, abortion opponents left a postcard-sized picture of a fetus – with the words “I AM A PERSON” – under the windshield wipers of the vehicles Iowa Republican activists drove to the event on the fairgrounds. 

Here’s the AUDIO of Henderson’s Radio Iowa report on this story.