• Home
  • News
    • Politics & Government
    • Business & Economy
    • Crime / Courts
    • Health / Medicine
  • Sports
    • High School Sports
    • Radio Iowa Poll
  • Affiliates
    • Affiliate Support Page
  • Contact Us
    • Reporters

Radio Iowa

Iowa's Radio News Network

You are here: Home / Crime / Courts / Supreme Court decision raises questions about inconsistent verdicts

Supreme Court decision raises questions about inconsistent verdicts

December 20, 2010 By Dar Danielson

An Iowa Supreme Court decision has raised questions about the way the state’s judges will handle inconsistent jury verdicts. The high court ruled last week that a jury was inconsistent in 2008 when they convicted David Halstead of Sioux City of assault while committing a felony, but acquitted him of the underlying felony theft charge.

Kevin Cmelik with the Attorney General’s office says these kinds of verdicts are not uncommon and Iowa and most other states have allowed them to stand.

“Juries will sometimes do things for irrational reasons and that’s why the inconsistent verdict rule developed,” Cmelik says, “The court just didn’t want to look into the mind of the jurors and try to decide why jurors were doing what they were doing when it sometimes reflected not an exercise in judgment, but an exercise in leniency.”

Cmelik says the ruling raises new questions for Judges. “What does the court do when it receives an inconsistent verdict? Does it tell the jury to go back and deliberate again, does it simply grant judgment of acquittal on the remaining offense? I don’t that the decision necessarily answers that question but it’s certainly going to affect cases in the future,” Cmelik says.

Cmelik says it is not clear yet whether this ruling will be applied retroactively. He says that question will undoubtedly be raised during someone else’s appeal.

Share this:

  • Facebook
  • Twitter

Filed Under: Crime / Courts

Featured Stories

Exhibit features lesser known works of Grant Wood

Testing finds 21 new CWD cases in deer

It may become a crime in Iowa to use fake urine in workplace drug tests

February trending 18 degrees below average temperature

Iowa House Education Committee votes to end tenure at UI, ISU, UNI

TwitterFacebook
Tweets by RadioIowa

New look and new format at girls’ state basketball

Youngstown State takes action against assistant football coach

Iowa’s Jack Nunge lost for the season

Key stretch begins for #9 Iowa

Drake’s Roman Penn lost for the season

More Sports

eNews and Updates

Enter your email address:

Delivered by FeedBurner

Archives

Copyright © 2021 · Learfield News & Ag, LLC