• Home
  • News
    • Politics & Government
    • Business & Economy
    • Crime / Courts
    • Health / Medicine
  • Sports
    • High School Sports
    • Radio Iowa Poll
  • Affiliates
    • Affiliate Support Page
  • Contact Us
    • Reporters

Radio Iowa

Iowa's Radio News Network

You are here: Home / Crime / Courts / Appeals court turns down challenge of judicial retention ballots

Appeals court turns down challenge of judicial retention ballots

December 7, 2011 By Dar Danielson

The Iowa Court of Appeals has turned down an appeal that sought to throw out the ballots in the election where three Iowa Supreme Court justices were voted off the bench. Three attorneys filed the lawsuit saying the retention vote on the judges was not valid because the votes were on the same ballot as the elected officials in the general election in November of 2010.

They Iowa Constitution requires that the votes on judges be on separate ballots. The district court dismissed the lawsuit saying the three had “not established either a personal or legal interest” in the litigation or showed they had been injured by the use of the combined ballot. The lower court also said the ballot did not fall under an exemption where the court could rule it was illegal for the “greater public good.”

The appeals court upheld the lower court ruling, saying, the plaintiffs failed to present a case of sufficient public importance to justify overturning the use of the ballots. And  it also said others such as judges or justices directly affected by judicial elections are better situated to bring a challenge.

The court’s chief justice, Rosemary Sackett issued a dissent in the case. Sackett said she could not agree with the other judges that an individual does not have a right to challenge the state’s alleged failure to construct a ballot in a manner so that it is constitutional.

And Sackett said “the right to vote and to have one’s vote counted is of a personal and legal interest to any citizen entitled to cast a ballot.”

See the complete ruling here: Ballots PDF

Share this:

  • Facebook
  • Twitter

Filed Under: Crime / Courts, News

Featured Stories

Summit has easements for 20% of carbon pipeline route through Iowa

Morel mushroom hunters on hold without warmer conditions

Trinity Health aquiring all MercyOne health properties

Field of Dreams site developer wants to bid on state baseball, softball tournaments

Governor gets bill targeting Iowa bars deemed ‘public safety nuisance’

TwitterFacebook
Tweets by RadioIowa

Radio Iowa/Baseball Coaches Association High School Poll 5/16/22

Iowa assistant coach Kirk Speraw to retire

Northern Iowa prepares for Missouri Valley Conference softball tournament

T.J. Otzelberger announces staff changes at Iowa State

Iowa State adds transfer guard

More Sports

eNews and Updates

Enter your email address:

Delivered by FeedBurner

Archives

Copyright © 2022 · Learfield News & Ag, LLC