• Home
  • News
    • Politics & Government
    • Business & Economy
    • Crime / Courts
    • Health / Medicine
  • Sports
    • High School Sports
    • Radio Iowa Poll
  • Affiliates
    • Affiliate Support Page
  • Contact Us
    • Reporters

Radio Iowa

Iowa's Radio News Network

You are here: Home / Crime / Courts / Supreme Court tries to determine if all white jury gave man unbiased trial

Supreme Court tries to determine if all white jury gave man unbiased trial

September 18, 2018 By Dar Danielson

Shellie Knipfer

The Iowa Supreme Court heard oral arguments in two cases today where those convicted of crimes say they did not get a fair trial based on the racial makeup of the jury.

Much of the discussion centered on how you determine the racial mix of a community and how that then translates to selecting a jury that’s representative of the community.

Attorney Shellie Knipfer argued on behalf of Kenneth Lilly of Fort Madison, who appealed his first degree robbery conviction. “Mr. Lilly’s all-white jury pool was not a fair crosssection of the community — and therefore he was denied his right to an unbiased jury under the federal and state constitutions,” Knipfer says.

The Supreme Court justices questioned Knipfer about whether it is still an issue in a county that has an extremely low number of minorities. “Whether you are dealing with small numbers or large numbers it makes a difference…When you have a three percent populations and there are absolutely no members — that should be statistically significant,” she says.

She was asked if counties with prisons should have those prisoners removed from the numbers used to determine population and she says they should The justices also asked if the population numbers should also be reduced for people under age 18 who would not be eligible to serve on a jury. Knipfer says the numbers would have to be looked at carefully. “Does it take into fact the high infant mortality rate of African-Americans compared to Caucasians? You have to justify that calculation and make sure it takes into consideration other aspects,” according to Knipfer.

Louis Sloven

Attorney Louis Sloven represented the state and says it is often hard to get an exact look at the makeup of the population. He says it also depends on how many people show up for the jury pool. “The calculations that you can do here show that there is no unfair or unreasonable underrepresentation. Even if there had been zero distinctive group members — in any sample under a hundred people — you really wouldn’t show a significant level of underrepresentation,” Sloven says.

Sloven was asked about taking data from previous jury pools and using it to determine if a new pool is representative. “So the problem is that it allows a claim to be made even if the current jury pool is perfectly representative or over representative. Even if the current jury pool is entirely composed of members of that particular distinctive group — you can aggregate data back far enough where you can find a significant level of underrepresentation,” according to Sloven.

Sloven was asked about areas that have very small minority populations and he says it is hard to say a pool is not representative when that population is below three percent. “Once you start getting slightly above three and into four, you can find a significant effect with a jury panel of reasonable size,” Sloven says. ” If the defendant is on the cusp, then I think it might be appropriate for a judge who is dealing with an issue that has been raised by the part to say — it might be appropriate to combine jury panels in this instance for the purpose of vindicating this right. Or at least making sure we are not violating it.”

The court heard a similar case in the convictions of Peter Veal of Lake Mills on two counts of first-degree murder and one count of attempt to commit murder. Veal argues the jury pools were unconstitutional.

 

Share this:

  • Facebook
  • Twitter

Filed Under: Crime / Courts, News

Featured Stories

Grundy Center man sentenced to life for killing State Trooper

Jodi Husientruit remembered 27 years after she disappeared

Iowa Supreme Court rules in Mahaska-Marion County regional airport dispute

Pheasant harvest and hunter numbers both up this year

Iowa Supreme Court overturns ruling creating constitutional abortion right

TwitterFacebook
Tweets by RadioIowa

Radio Iowa/Baseball Coaches Association High School Poll 6/27/22

AJ Green signs with Milwaukee

Iowa to host Georgia Tech in ACC/Big Ten Challenge

Iowa State adds a defensive back

Radio Iowa/Baseball Coaches Association High School Poll 6/20/22

More Sports

eNews and Updates

Enter your email address:

Delivered by FeedBurner

Archives

Copyright © 2022 ยท Learfield News & Ag, LLC