May 23, 2013

11th hour negotiations lead to “Iowa Healthy & Well Plan”

Linda Upmeyer

Linda Upmeyer

Legislators have voted to create a new “Iowa Healthy and Well Plan” that meets the governor’s demand for an “Iowa solution” to providing some sort of insurance coverage to up to 150,000 low-income Iowans. The deal was hatched by two north central Iowa lawmakers.

Republican Governor Terry Branstad has repeatedly said he would not accept federal money to expand the number of Iowans who qualify for Medicaid. Democratic Senator Jack Hatch threatened a sort of legislative blockade over the dispute, but Senate President Pam Jochum credits two other female legislators with finding the right pathway.

“The two of them met last week and the door opened,” Jochum told reporters.

House Republican Leader Linda Upmeyer of Clear Lake is one half of the duo credited with crafting the compromise.

Amanda-Ragan

Amanda Ragan

“I think when you start with here’s what we agree with — you know, we agree on all these things, so let’s look, then, how we can resolve the places where we don’t agree,” Upmeyer says. “I think women are very good at that.”

Senator Amanda Ragan, a Democrat from Mason City, said the discussion didn’t just happen overnight and involved getting the right people in the room at the right time.

“I think both of us can walk away very proud of the work that we did,” Ragan said.

According to Ragan, it shows the kind of gridlock that’s immobilized Washington, D.C. hasn’t trickled down to the Iowa legislature.  Upmeyer and Ragan represent the same area of the state. Half of Ragan’s Senate district is Upmeyer’s House district.

Impasse over health care reform may be resolved

There’s been another statehouse breakthrough today. This one comes on a health are issue that had threatened to derail efforts to conclude the 2013 legislative session.

A tentative agreement has emerged that would use federal funds to provide government subsidies so low-income Iowans can buy private health insurance. Republican Governor Terry Branstad had resisted Democrats’ call to simply enroll up to 150,000 more Iowans in Medicaid. This new plan will be called Iowa Health and Wellness Plan and House Republican Leader Linda Upmeyer of Clear Lake is one of its architects.

“I’m really pleased with the outcome,” Upmeyer says. “Everybody moved their position a little bit in order to do the right thing by Iowans and the result is an Iowa solution for Iowans and I’m excited about that.”

Senate President Pam Jochum, a Democrat from Dubuque, is another legislator involved in the behind-the-scenes negotiations.

“We all really wanted to make sure that these 150,000 Iowans had health insurance,” Jochum says. “So there was a lot of give and take on both sites and at this point there’s a tentative agreement and we’re hoping that it becomes law.”

Nearly 90,000 Iowans who have an income that’s below the poverty line would get a government subsidy to buy into a health insurance plan just like those offered to state employees. Iowans who have an income that’s within 101 and 138 percent of the poverty line would get a subsidy, too, to buy a plan that’ll be offered on the new “insurance exchange” being set up in Iowa.  The state would accept federal money to cover those subsidies, something that had been a sticking point for Republicans who say the federal government can’t afford it.

Governor Branstad has repeatedly said he wants an “Iowa solution” that ensures participants have “skin in the game” and under this compromise those who fail to follow doctor’s orders for a healthier lifestyle — like giving up cigarettes — would have to start paying a part of their premiums in year two.

Governor says “nobody’s going to get their way totally” in health care debate

Republican Governor Terry Branstad is opening the door to a compromise health care plan that might merge his “Healthy Iowa Plan” with Senate Democrats’ plan to expand Medicaid to cover low-income, uninsured Iowans.

“‘We’ve got the senate that wants to buy ObamaCare lock, stock and barrel and we’ve got the House that doesn’t want to do anything,” Branstad says. “…We’re going to continue to talk to both House and Senate members about this and…it’s just like the other things we’ve been working on. If we’re going to get something resolved, nobody’s going to get their way totally.”

About 52 percent of the cost of Branstad’s “Healthy Iowa Plan” would be covered by state government and 48 percent by the federal government. Democrats counter that by expanding Medicaid to cover more uninsured Iowans, the federal government will cover 100 percent of that cost for the first three years and then 90 percent after that.

“That is one of the things that we’re willing to consider, provided there’s assurance that if the federal dollars are reduced, the Iowa taxpayers don’t get stuck,” Branstad says.

Democrats have offered to put that stipulation into a bill, but Branstad says it’s the kind of assurance that can only come from federal officials.

The governor made his comments this morning during his weekly statehouse news conference. Listen to the audio here.

Legislator makes appeal for “reassurance” from governor

Dave Heaton

Dave Heaton

Key legislators say there could be a breakthrough in negotiations over exactly how the state may ensure more low-income working Iowans get health care coverage.

Representative Dave Heaton, a Republican from Mount Pleasant who is involved in the negotiations, puts it like this:  ”I think reassurance from the governor’s office that he is respecting our work at trying to find a compromise between his plan and the Senate plan would be very helpful in helping us move forward.”

Democrats have been pushing to use available federal dollars to expand the government’s Medicaid program to provide coverage to up to 150,000 uninsured Iowans.

Republican Governor Terry Branstad’s proposed alternative creates a whole new “Healthy Iowa Plan” the is heavily subsidized by the state and federal government and requires a monthly premium payment of $12 from the roughly 90,000 uninsured Iowans it’s designed to cover.

“We believe that there are things going on now that are opening the door for us to determine whether or not the executive branch is serious,” says Senator Jack Hatch, a Democrat from Des Moines who is also involved in the private negotiations.

Hatch and Heaton are part of a 10-member committee that was appointed a couple of weeks ago to try to hammer out a compromise. Heaton says once everyone is on “the same wavelength” negotiations may take off.

“If you’re going to sit down and you’re really going to find a real compromise, it takes a lot of trust…that we really are sincere in what we are saying and doing in trying to find a final conclusion to what the differences are,” Heaton says, “and can trust each other that somebody isn’t going to go out and try to do something else.”

Legislators have a host of issues to resolve before their 2013 session can end — and the end won’t come this week. Lawmakers will come back to the capitol next week to continue debate on this topic and a host of others.

Democrats make “skin in the game” offer to GOP on health care

There’s a new wrinkle in on-going statehouse discusses over how best to provide health care coverage to low-income Iowans who are uninsured today.

Democrats in the legislature who simply want to expand the existing Medicaid program to cover 150,000 more Iowans are offering to link co-pays for all current and future Medicaid recipients to health and wellness initiatives. Senator Jack Hatch, a Democrat from Des Moines, says Democrats would waive those co-pays for those who get regular check-ups and take steps to improve their health, like quitting smoking or losing weight, but a trip to the emergency room for a minor health issue would require a co-pay.

“We’re going to ask patients to participate in their own health care,” Hatch says. “…The Republicans have talked about ‘skin in the game.’ We’re going to include that in our proposal.”

Republican Governor Terry Branstad’s “Healthy Iowa Plan” requires a monthly premium payment of $10, but premiums could be reduced for those who take steps to improve their health. Senator David Johnson, a Republican from Ocheyedan, says there’s “still a long way to go” before the gap between Democrats and Republicans is bridged.

“It’s opened the door a crack, I would say,” Johnson says of this latest offer from Democrats.

Johnson is a member of the 10-member conference committee appointed to find a compromise.

“We’ve got one week left to go in this session according to leadership,” Johnson says. “This is some heavy lifting that has to be done in order to reach an agreement, so anything’s possible — including a special session.”

Senate President Pam Jochum, a Democrat from Dubuque, is expressing optimism.

“I think we are actually moving a little closer to the middle,” Jochum told reporters this afternoon, “and I am hopeful that we are going to find some kind of a solution to this before we adjourn.”

Senate Democratic Leader Mike Gronstal says he’s ”beyond optimistic” that lawmakers can wrap up the work of the 2013 legislative session next week.

Most of House GOP approves governor’s “Healthy Iowa Plan”

Fifty-one Republicans in the Iowa House have formally endorsed Governor Terry Branstad’s ”Healthy Iowa Plan” to provide insurance coverage to low-income Iowans who live just below the poverty line.

Representative Dave Heaton, a Republican from Mount Pleasant, was a reluctant yes.

“I’m going to vote for this bill today so that we can get together with the senate and sit down and figure a better bill,” Heaton said, “to correct some of the things that I think are wrong with it and I think a lot of the people in this room think is wrong with it.”

Heaton faults the governor’s plan for creating waiting lists for health care services and using $85.5 million in property taxes to help pay for the coverage. Representative Walt Rogers, a Republican from Cedar Falls, defended the governor’s plan.

“We can be a leader here in the State of Iowa, a leader in our country,” Rogers said to close tonight’s debate, “putting forth a plan that helps people invest in their own health care, helps people become healthier.”

In late March Senate Democrats passed a different plan that would enroll up to 150,000 low-income Iowans who don’t have insurance in Medicaid. Republican Representative Chip Baltimore of Boone said legislators can’t trust the feds to pay for it.

“To rely 100 percent on the federal government for a massive expansion of permanent program and ignore the alternative that we have…an Iowa-based program for Iowans is simply a folly,” Baltimore said.

Democrats like Representative Bruce Hunter of Des Moines argued Branstad’s plan costs Iowa taxpayers more and covers fewer Iowans.

“It’s time for Iowans to stand up and decide that health care coverage should be sent to 150,000 instead of 89,000 people,” Hunter said.

Two House Republicans — Representative Josh Byrnes of Osage and Brian Moore of Bellevue — did not vote for the governor’s plan while the other 51 Republicans votes yes. All 47 Democrats in the House voted no.

Senate votes to create new state tax credit for small businesses (AUDIO)

The Iowa Senate has unanimously voted to create a new state tax credit for Iowa small businesses that provide health care benefits to their workers.

Senator Matt McCoy, a Democrat from Des Moines, said small business owners pay, on average, about 18 percent more than large businesses to provide health care coverage to their employees.

“This tax credit is one step in an effort to bring down health care costs and make coverage affordable for all small businesses,” McCoy said.

McCoy estimated 73,000 Iowa small businesses with fewer than 25 employees would qualify for this new credit.

“We have a long ways to go,” McCoy said, “but the markers are set now and we are moving towards a goal and ultimately the goal is to provide every Iowan with health coverage and that is a goal that we will accomplish if we work together.”

Businesses with fewer than 25 employees already are eligible for a new federal tax credit if they provide health care coverage to workers. The bill that passed the Iowa Senate would let those same small businesses in Iowa claim 25 percent of their federal tax credit as a state credit.

Senator Jack Hatch, a Democrat from Des Moines, explained the math: ”If a company spends $50,000 a year on employee health benefits, combined with the federal tax credit that they can obtain plus the new state tax credit we will be able give them, they will be able to get $21,875 back.”

Democrats and Republicans in the Senate supported this new tax credit. Senator Jake Chapman, a Republican from Adel, said his family owns “several businesses” that could take advantage of this new tax credit.

“But you know I think it’s interesting that the federal government passed an Affordable Care Act,” Chapman said. “If it was affordable, why are we doing tax credits to help these small businesses? It’s because it’s not affordable.”

AUDIO of senate debate of SF449 (mp3 runs about 12 min.)

If the Iowa House goes along with the idea, this new tax credit would apply for the current 2013 tax year. A small business owner could use the new credit to off-set any kind of tax payments they owe the state for their business — and they would get a refund from the state if the amount of the credit is larger than what they owe in taxes.